- Details
- By Jacob Malcom, Next Interior
- Opinion | Op-Ed
EDITOR'S NOTE: We're excited to feature analysis from Next Interior, a new policy platform launched in 2025 that focuses exclusively on the U.S. Department of the Interior. Founded by Jacob Malcom, former director of policy analysis at Interior, Next Interior publishes detailed policy memoranda that offer unflinching analysis of what's happening at the department. For Tribal Business News readers, Malcom will be providing special briefings that focus specifically on Indian Country issues within Interior policy, drawing from his insider knowledge to help tribal leaders understand and respond to federal decisions that affect their communities.
_____________________
It’s good to hear when leaders recognize real problems, but not-so-good if the solutions they propose are highly suspect.
That’s one of the take-aways from the Western Governors’ Association (WGA) annual meeting in Santa Fe, New Mexico. The Western states, Indian Country, and the Department of the Interior all depend on and influence each other, so it made sense for Next Interior to attend and engage with folks at the 2025 meeting. Issues ranged from energy development to housing in the West, and from wildland fire to invasive species and native seeds. But one topic was particularly concerning: the proposal to use generative AI to address the (massive) backlog of Tribal probate cases across Indian Country.
To be clear, the backlog of probate cases isn’t an issue that Secretary of the Interior Burgum made up; it is a very big problem. Decades of underfunding for the Department and complex laws mean that Tribal members—to whom the U.S. Government has an obligation to fulfill trust responsibilities like this—aren’t being served.
When asked by one of the governors for a specific application of AI for Interior, the Secretary said, basically, “We’re going to create bots that read every case in probate law…we’ll have the smartest Indian probate lawyer ever. And then we’ll make 1,000 of them and put them to work to resolve all these cases, clear this backlog.”
The problem is that almost every single week we get new cases reported where lawyers use generative AI tools to write briefs…that are riddled with errors. This situation and proposal from the Secretary should make everyone pause and ask, What kind of disaster is this going to mean for Indian Country, for those people who deserve to have their cases resolved? How many cases are going to be wrongly decided because the bots hallucinate facts or case law? How much time and effort will be lost trying to undo those mistakes?
Interested in Next Interior’s full run-down of Burgum's proposed AI fix and the entire WGA meeting—the good, the bad, and the suspect? You can read it here.
Jacob Malcom is the founder of Next Interior and former Director of Policy Analysis at the U.S. Department of the Interior. He previously held field and leadership roles at Interior and spent nearly a decade in conservation policy at Defenders of Wildlife.